Dental voucher plan criticised amid NHS dentistry crisis

Dental Tribune International

Wed. 7 January 2026

save

LONDON, England: A proposed dental voucher scheme has reignited debate over the future of National Health Service (NHS) dentistry in England. The idea, set out by a policy think-tank, is being promoted as a way to improve access for adult patients. Professional bodies say it misunderstands the depth of the crisis facing the service.

NHS dentistry remains one of the most visible pressure points in the health system, and limited access is now entrenched across much of England. Patients routinely report difficulty finding practices willing to take them on, while dentists continue to scale back NHS work or leave the system entirely. It is within this context that a new voucher model has entered the policy debate.

The proposal, outlined in a recent report by think-tank Policy Exchange, suggests the provision to every adult of a dental voucher to the value of £150 (€171^*) to spend on treatment directly or use towards a dental insurance policy. The voucher would replace the current system, which has been widely acknowledged to be failing.

The British Dental Association (BDA), however, has responded critically. From the profession’s perspective, the problem stems from chronic underfunding and an unsustainable contract. Speaking on the matter, BDA Chair Dr Eddie Crouch said in a press release: “Calls for a voucher system in NHS dentistry come with the sound of barrels being scraped. NHS desperately needs investment, but this policy would not end dental deserts. It could easily mean spending more money on less access. A struggling service urgently requires real reform and sustainable funding. We don’t need distractions, or detours into ideological comfort zones.”

The BDA has also raised the concern that the proposal shifts responsibility away from government and on to patients. By focusing on consumer choice, critics argue, the model essentially ignores the structural flaws of the NHS dental contract that dentists say makes public work unattractive and financially unsustainable. Without reform to how NHS dentistry is funded and delivered, the association believes that vouchers would replace NHS dentistry for adults without guaranteeing that the resulting market would deliver equitable or sufficient access. The BDA argues that the proposal would risk normalising reduced NHS provision rather than restoring it.

Others have warned that such a scheme could deepen inequalities. In areas with higher private charges or fewer practices, patients would have little real choice about how to use the voucher. Professional bodies continue to call for direct investment, contract reform and a credible workforce plan to stabilise NHS dentistry. As access problems worsen, the BDA’s message is that policy debates must focus on rebuilding of the service and not on proposals that offer more money without more care.

Editorial note:

^* Calculated on the OANDA platform for 15 December 2025.